Ember Online

what if when they steal they have a small chance of getting an item like the sellable junk or potions/food nothing major though

I'd only be okay with this if it was an attack action like /mug with all the associated chances to miss or be deflected. Then people could still /rob for gold only but /mug for a chance of getting something else. Could have it work like backstab in that someone has to be hidden first. Even could combine the two attack types to when someone hides and uses /mug they do (0.5 to 2) x damage, take a little gold, and have a chance for something out of inventory.

+1 for giving thieves the ability to mug people

i like that ppl expanded on my basic idea now if the main ppl agree with it

Kruell wrote:I'd only be okay with this if it was an attack action like /mug with all the associated chances to miss or be deflected. Then people could still /rob for gold only but /mug for a chance of getting something else. Could have it work like backstab in that someone has to be hidden first. Even could combine the two attack types to when someone hides and uses /mug they do (0.5 to 2) x damage, take a little gold, and have a chance for something out of inventory.

I agree with this, I think it would work like a half rob/half attack (both apply but at half effectiveness each or some such), the inventory item could be something minor that it drops or from some random generic table based on beastie type at a slightly lower than usual chance (since you normal only get something when something is killed), also maybe a limit of one item/chance to stop cheese).